DOJ defends Trump’s post as it urges judge to reject Comey’s effort to dismiss case
WASHINGTON — The Justice Department urged a federal judge Monday to reject James Comey’s claim that his prosecution amounts to political retribution, arguing the former FBI director has failed to show that he’s being targeted as punishment for his criticism of the Republican president.
Prosecutors defended President Donald Trump’s September social media post demanding that action be taken in the Comey investigation, contending it reflects “legitimate prosecutorial motive” and is no basis to dismiss the indictment accusing Comey of lying to Congress in 2020.
The filing underscores how Trump’s comments have put the Justice Department in a difficult position as Comey and other defendants seize on the president’s remarks in efforts to have their cases dismissed ahead of trial. Comey’s lawyers told the judge last month that the charges must be thrown out because they were brought out of “personal spite” at the direction of the president. A lawyer for New York Attorney General Letitia James, another Trump foe who’s been charged in a mortgage fraud investigation, has signaled that he will make a similar argument.
The Justice Department acknowledged that Trump’s social media posts reflect the president’s view that Comey “committed crimes that should be met with prosecution” and “may even suggest that the President disfavors the defendant.” But, prosecutors argued, there is “not direct evidence of a vindictive motive.”
“The defendant spins a tale that requires leaps of logic and a big dose of cynicism, then he calls the President’s post a direct admission,” prosecutors wrote. “There is no direct admission of discriminatory purpose. To the contrary, the only direct admission from the President is that DOJ officials decided whether to prosecute, not him.”
The dispute concerns arguably the most closely watched of several challenges Comey has brought over the indictment, with Comey’s attorneys citing not only Trump’s public demands for prosecutions of his perceived enemies but also his longtime disdain for the former FBI director, whom he fired during his first term amid the Russia election interference investigation.
Patrick Fitzgerald, the former U.S. attorney in Chicago and a longtime Comey friend, has argued that Trump’s social media post calling on Attorney General Pam Bondi to prosecute Comey and other longtime foes “constitutes a direct admission of discriminatory purpose to single out a perceived political enemy.”
