One year data center moratorium established
For unincorporated areas of Brown County
Trending
NEW ULM -- Brown County has established a one year moratorium effective Nov. 17 on the establishment of data centers within the unincorporated areas of Brown County following a public hearing Tuesday morning.
Planning and Zoning Director Robert Santaella clarified the moratorium does not cover cities within Brown County, and that they would have to establish their own ordinances.
Establishing a moratorium will give county staff time to research the impacts of data centers and establish standards to follow in the event that a company were to approach Brown County about creating a data center in the area.
As of right now, Brown County has not been approached about data center possibilities, so the moratorium is a proactive measure.
Before motioning the establishment of the moratorium, members of the public came forward to share their input about data centers.
Theresa Keaveny of New Ulm emphasized the importance of public input with every potential instance of a data center coming to the area. She also pointed out quality of life concerns.
"It would be my hope that we would ensure that siting of the data centers doesn't adversely affect the neighbors," Keaveny said.
She shared concerns about water and utility consumption by data centers and hoped that ordinances would ensure that the water and utility used by data centers would not impact community usage.
Lastly, Keaveny said transparency is a must and NDAs (Non-disclosure agreement) should be avoided.
Commissioner Anton Berg, who has attended multiple meetings on data centers with fellow commissioners, said that workshops were adamant not to sign NDAs with data center companies.
Laura Way, who moved to the area from Minneapolis, urged Commissioners to think of the impacts on future generations.
"For folks like me and my children, we're going to be dealing with the impacts of these a lot longer than a lot of the folks in this room," Way said.
Way said that the one year moratorium should be a bare minimum, ensuring enough time to conduct research and review case studies.
"We live in a beautiful river valley and I would like to keep it that way," Way said.
Commissioner David Borchert agreed with Way, saying he did his own research and shared environmental concerns. He also agreed that they were responsible for helping create a safe future for the next generations.
"I think technology's gone past where science and society can adapt to it and deal with stuff safely," Borchert said. "So I think as much research we can do and making well-informed decisions and having that public feedback is extremely valuable."
Community member Vicki Pearson said that data centers are unsafe and the companies moving into the area are interested in profit.
"There's nothing in it for us other than a destruction of our area," Pearson said.
Commissioner Brian Braun compared data centers to hog farming.
"Everybody wants to have some bacon, but nobody wants to have the hog barn next to them," Braun said. "Everybody wants to have fast internet, everybody wants to be able to make documents and edit their pictures and things like that, but nobody wants to have a data center right next to them."
He was in favor of the moratorium because it will help establish zoning while also addressing water usage, energy consumption, pollution and noise concerns.
Allen Mathiowitz of Morgan countered Bruan's claim.
"I happen to be part of the older generation and I don't need any more of that stuff, nor do I want it.
Mathiowitz brought up energy priority and personal information privacy concerns if data centers move into the area. He said Morgan has livestock and grain facilities that require constant power.
"Who gets priority?"
Commissioner Scott Windschitl empathized with Minnesotans who have dealt with data centers moving into their areas.
"I couldn't stand living next to something like that, a constant hum, they drive you crazy," Windschitl said.
Anton Berg made a motion to approve the interim ordinance establishing a one year moratorium on data centers with unanimous approval.