Mobile Version: mobile.nujournal.com
RSS:
New Ulm Weather Forecast, MN
Member Login: Email: Password:
Search: Local News Classified Web
News  Obituaries  Opinion  Agribusiness  Polls  Sports  Blogs  Communities  Industry of the Year  Classifieds  Jobs  CU Galleries
Letters

Cherusci, Dakota both resisted colonization

POSTED: September 15, 2009

To the editor:

"We must tell our children and our children's children the story of the heroes of every land and every time who have given their lives that liberty and fraternity and equality might survive among men."

- Governor David Marston Clough, Dedication of Hermann Monument, New Ulm, Minnesota

This is a letter to those who remember that before they were Americans, before they were Germans, they were Chatti, Cherusi, Harii, Marsi and Suebia.

This is a letter to those who remember their own homeland and the ways of their ancestors; to those who remain Tru.

This is a letter to those who remember that they too were once resistors of colonization.

This is a letter to those who remember Hermann Der Cherusker.

Two thousand years ago on this date, a handful of tribes were united for a brief glimpse in history. Deep in the forests of Teutoburg, these few thousand warriors stood against three legions of the greatest empire of their time. For three days, they fought for their existence as a People, driving the Romans out of their homelands, and holding them at bay for 400 years until the Empire's collapse.

Rome was the greatest colonizing force of its time, with armies that rode out and conquered much of the known world. It brought thousands of Europe's indigenous peoples under colonial rule through superior weapons, tactics and numbers. Yet, as written in the words of the Romans themselves, Hermann der Cherusker "challenged the Roman people not in its beginnings like other kings and leaders, but in the peak of its empire."

Approximately 1400 years later, in a land called Mnisota Makoce, indigenous peoples would stand again to combat the New Rome. Just as the Chatti, the Cherusi, and the Marsi tribes fought against an invading imperial army, our People, the Dakota Oyate, fought against our own invading empire and defended our own way of life.

And once again, members of the Chatti, the Chersci, and the Marsi would be present for this battle, but only after their own assimilation. The descendants of those who had once defended their lands against a colonial power so many centuries before would decide to dishonor their ancestors, betray their heritage, and ally themselves with the New Rome.

The citizens of New Ulm, descendants of Hermann der Cherusker, Uniter of Tribes, Defier of Rome, Resistor of Empires, would become perpetrators of colonialism against those who should have been their relations in a common struggle.

And so, the Dakota resistance came with much pain. Our women and children were force-marched to concentration camps before exile from our homelands. It was through the town of New Ulm that German-Americans threw rocks and harassed these captives. Boiling water was poured from windows onto passing elders and children. One young man was even pulled from the procession and severely beaten by the mob. His older brother was killed in the process of saving him.

Tribute is rightfully paid to Hermann, and two statues commemorate his resistance. One on a hill near the site of the Battle of the Teutoburg Forest. Another, 4,000 miles away in the town of New Ulm, in the heart of Dakota Territory.

While it is an honor that a tribute to a hero of liberation stands amongst us, it is both sad and ironic that the fields next to him stand empty, where a monument to the successful defenders of Dakota homeland should have stood had another people remembered their own tribal past. That emptiness is now only filled with the painful memories of the loss of our homeland, the genocide of our people, and the betrayal of descendants of a far-away tribe.

Tonight, we put out tobacco for all the descendants of Hermann der Cherusker, for the descendants of all who stood with him, and for our own ancestors who continued their fight. We do this in hopes that these descendants might remember the commonalities between our two peoples and our two struggles.

It is up to you to also honor those ancestors and to continue their fight. Stand with us, as you stand with them, and forever resist the New Rome.

In the Spirit of Hermann der Cherusker,

In the Spirit of Taoyateduta,

Unki tamakoce k'a oni unkitawapi!

Anpao Duta dena unkiyepi

Granite Falls

 
Share:
Facebook  MySpace  Digg  Stumble    Mixx  Fark  del.icio.us   LiveSpaces
 
Member Comments
View Comments: | 1-8 | Post a comment
middleclassworker
09-18-09 4:48 PM
Either way, everything is in the past. You and I and everybody else in the world had nothing to do with wars against Native Americans. It's time we quit dwelling on this like we should all feel some personal responsibility. There are enough other issues in the world to deal with.

serenity1122
09-18-09 12:07 PM
superduper,

Of course it would. Its strange to think, even for an instant, that resistance to institutionalized oppression is wrong.

And to correct tooold here, until European contact, war amongst Native peoples very rarely involved killing. Scalping is a European practice. War for most Indigenous societies was a kind of glorified play. It is against Native world view to try and end the existence of a population, or even an individual. Its true everyone had enemies and friends, but they aren't defined the way we would normally think of them. Native warfare was much more humane than say, WWI or WWII, where literally millions were slaughtered. And the US invasion of Minnesota was hardly just warfare. Hitler said repeatedly how much he admired the US for its efficient policy against Native peoples.

superduper
09-17-09 8:34 AM
Norwaymaple, would that statement be applicable to all people, including the Dakota, other Native Americans, the Phillipino, and other peoples who have fought back American oppression?

Norwaymaple
09-16-09 8:02 PM
Tooold, don't forget that war is forced upon us sometimes, and it is the right course to make things right against oppression.

tooold
09-16-09 10:42 AM
War is awful--no matter who or where it is fought. The lands are never the same after a war. Lest anyone forget that the Native Americans also fought each other. The Sioux were once in Northern Minnesota but the Ojibwe fought them and they went further south. Human beings are not always nice people--even Germans--Native Americans--English--Romans etc. War is never the right course--but we can never go back. We should learn from history--not repeat it.

middleclassworker
09-15-09 7:19 PM
Sorry, I wasn't aiming at offending anyone. I guess we all take shots day after day, some of us shrug them off, I guess you took offense. My apologies to you. On a side note, yes, it was horrible what happened, but how long are we to feel guilty? I had no say in the actions that took place...my ancestors weren't even over here yet, so does that put me off the hook? Also, for millenniums, countries have been fighting countries and claiming land and rule. Where are the letters there? Do the Germans write into the Italian newspapers because they are offended that the Romans killed so many of their ancestors trying to take their land? Yes, I agree with the writer that it was a travesty...all wars are. I appreciate his letter. My comment was simply a bit of dry humor, I guess. I meant no harm.

marthastuckey
09-15-09 4:51 PM
middleclassworker, I appreciate the time you took to read this letter. But, as a New Ulm-ite with an interest in colonialism and in correcting our past injustices I find your comment insensitive and racist. To the author of the letter, thank you for bringing this to our attention. While we pride in our history with large copper statues and parades, we shirk our more recent past too easily. A lesson for all of us in many ways, but especially important during this festival.

middleclassworker
09-15-09 12:20 AM
But our people brought you the internet!!

You must first login before you can comment.
Existing Member Login
Not a Member?
Create a Member Account  
*Your email address:
*Password:
    Forgot Password?
  Remember my email address.
 
News  Obituaries  Opinion  Agribusiness  Polls  Sports  Blogs  Communities  Industry of the Year  Classifieds  Jobs  CU Galleries